The Silicon Underground
  Welcome to Dave Farquhar's Silicon Underground Monday, November 23 2009 @ 01:03 PM CST  
Theme Changer
Change the look of the site by selecting a theme below:

What's New
STORIES
No new stories

COMMENTS last 48 hrs
  • Why don't wins co...

  • LINKS last 2 wks
    No recent new links

    Google Ads

    User Functions
    Username:

    Password:

    Don't have an account yet? Sign up as a New User

    Firefox


    Umm... Don't water-cool your power supply   
    Monday, January 13 2003 @ 01:02 AM CST
    By David L. Farquhar

    I saw a thing on Slashdot this morning about water-cooling your power supply. One word: Don't.

    I've worked inside a power supply twice--both times to replace a dead fan. One time I touched a heatsink that picked up a charge from somewhere--either a voltage regulator or a capacitor. Anyway, it really didn't feel good. Beyond that, it made me jump.

    Not a project you want to undertake if you don't know what you're doing. And if you do know what you're doing, you probably already know it isn't something you want to do be doing. Anyone who uses the word "electric" to describe something pleasant has obviously never experienced anything electric flowing through them.

    I'll pass, thanks.

      [ Views: 1155 ]  


    Umm... Don't water-cool your power supply | 5 comments | Create New Account
    The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
    David T.
    Authored by: ImportedComment on Monday, January 13 2003 @ 12:21 PM CST
    I'll pass too. I guess I'm getting old :-)

    Switching power supplies means that you are not only working with high currents, you are working with high frequencies as well. Not a good combination.

    Anyway, the person who wrote the article must be really bored :-)

    /Dave T.

    [ Reply to This ]

    Mark Odell
    Authored by: ImportedComment on Monday, January 13 2003 @ 05:35 PM CST
    As someone with experience around the innards of switching power supplies, I humbly concur with both Daves.

    And different models of switchers vary so much internally that IMPO this project absolutely should be left to the professionals, who are prepared to do the amount of checking required to ascertain whether or not a given heatsink is correctly insulated from high voltages: and for that matter whether or not it's even worthwhile to do. Sometimes, as Dave F. discovered shockingly ;), switcher designers will cut corners on little things like insulating heatsinks electrically.

    Besides, if someone's thinking about water-cooling a power supply because it runs "too hot", then it probably shouldn't even be in the case.

    [ Reply to This ]

    Pegasong
    Authored by: ImportedComment on Tuesday, January 14 2003 @ 04:22 PM CST
    I'd just as soon not touch the inside of anything electrical.

    I got a nice 750 volt shock off a piece of gear when I was in the navy. I shorted a rheostat to the side of a CRT. Zap! It put a very real fear of electricity in me.

    [ Reply to This ]

    Taran Rampersad
    Authored by: ImportedComment on Wednesday, January 15 2003 @ 10:24 AM CST
    Water cooling a power supply is about as brilliant as putting liquid sodium in the secondary of a nuclear reactor, when the primary has superheated steam...

    Oh wait, that's a soviet submarine power plant design. I suppose they didn't know what happens when sodium hits water...

    I still don't understand why power supplies are placed at the top of the tower, with the CPU heat sink typically right below it. This is the reverse of spot cooling - it seems that it is spot heating. There's so much room in a case, one wonders why they did that. Planned obsolescence?

    Somewhere, a hardware manufacturer is cackling hysterically...

    [ Reply to This ]

    Dave F.
    Authored by: ImportedComment on Wednesday, January 15 2003 @ 12:58 PM CST
    Tradition. It's always been in the top of the tower. And 10 years ago when the only fan in the case was the power supply fan, it was probably the most logical place for it. And towers are still pretty much just desktops flipped over; in 1981 that was definitely the most logical place for one since the power supply fan could get aiflow from the holes in the disk drives and the spaces between them.

    The I-Tee case I talked about elsewhere this week moves the power supply to the bottom though. Now that you mention it, that's probably the most important thing about that case.

    [ Reply to This ]

    What's Related
  • More by DaveF
  • More from Hardware

  • Story Options
  • Mail Story to a Friend
  • Printable Story Format


  • Calendar
    November 2009
    SuMoTuWeThFrSa
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10
    11
    12
    13
    14
    15
    16
    17
    18
    19
    20
    21
    22
    23
    24
    25
    26
    27
    28
    29
    30
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    Click on any day to see postings and events for that date.

    Referrals

    Top 10 by Comments
    Story TitleComments
    Cheap laptops from Sotec 253
    An untrustworthy vendor 164
    Upgrading an eMachine 125
    eMachine upgrade advice 99
    Why I dislike Microsoft 51
    Upgrade diary: Gateway G6-400 35
    And we're live 30
    The day after the Columbia 22
    How to pray 22
    CD-ROM troubleshooting under Windows 9x 20

    Top 10 Read
    Story TitleViews
    eMachine upgrade advice 74334
    Upgrading an eMachine 63084
    How to view a blg file in Windows 2000 50613
    Cheap laptops from Sotec 32796
    Upgrade diary: Compaq Presario 7360 19998
    Upgrade diary: Gateway G6-400 19874
    CD-ROM troubleshooting under Windows 9x 15550
    Finding an open-source alternative to Ghost 14293
    Big trouble 13817
    Salary cap? Baseball needs something 11800

    Topics
    Home
    Apache (2)
    Baseball (63)
    Book reviews (2)
    Business (1)
    Christianity (57)
    Cooking (1)
    Copyright (16)
    Curmudgeonry (1)
    Design (7)
    DOS (6)
    Games (4)
    Genealogy (11)
    General (507)
    Hardware (168)
    Health (13)
    Human Interest (9)
    Humor/Satire (19)
    Investing (4)
    Journalism (1)
    Linux (93)
    Macintosh (22)
    Model Building (3)
    Music (33)
    net.culture (40)
    Personal (88)
    Photography (6)
    Politics (3)
    Retro Computing (26)
    Saving money (72)
    Servers and Networking (18)
    Society (49)
    Software (55)
    Spam (13)
    St. Louis (23)
    This weblog (14)
    Toy trains (74)
    Troubleshooting (7)
    Useless Trivia (1)
    Vendors (6)
    Video (21)
    Viruses (12)
    Windows (120)
    Writing (16)

    Older Stories
    Wednesday 30-Sep
  • 401(K) Paperwork (0)

  • Sunday 27-Sep
  • First impressions: HP Mini 110 (1)

  • Saturday 26-Sep
  • Getting more screen real estate in Firefox (0)

  • Wednesday 23-Sep
  • Barfy. (4)

  • Monday 21-Sep
  • Why I quit my job (2)

  • Saturday 12-Sep
  • Slimming down Windows XP for SSDs and nettops (0)

  • Thursday 10-Sep
  • And... bailing out. (3)

  • Friday 04-Sep
  • End of the innocence (0)

  • Monday 31-Aug
  • Installing Windows off USB (1)

  • Friday 21-Aug
  • Diving into real estate (0)

  • Who's Online
    Guest Users: 7

    Syndicate!
    Get your RSS/RDF fix here.

    List of all stories
    Click here for a list of all the entries on this site


    Created this page in 1.91 seconds


     Copyright © 2009 Dave Farquhar's Silicon Underground
     All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners.

    Powered by GL 1.3.x