The Silicon Underground
  Welcome to Dave Farquhar's Silicon Underground Tuesday, October 07 2008 @ 01:04 AM CDT  
Theme Changer
Change the look of the site by selecting a theme below:

What's New
STORIES
1 story in last 24 hours

COMMENTS last 48 hrs
  • I got a Pentax K1...

  • LINKS last 2 wks
    No recent new links

    Google Ads

    User Functions
    Username:

    Password:

    Don't have an account yet? Sign up as a New User

    Firefox


    Dateline's getting sued   
    Tuesday, July 24 2007 @ 09:24 PM CDT
    By David L. Farquhar

    JournalismI see that Dateline's being sued because someone who found himself on the "To Catch a Predator" segment and killed himself. His sister is suing for $105 million.

    Good.

    I don't normally like lawsuits, but Dateline is the most despicable excuse for journalism in the entire world, and yes, I know that takes some doing. Remember, this is the same television show that decided that GM pickup trucks didn't explode spectacularly enough in collisions and rigged them with explosives, then presented this dramatization as fact.

    What Dateline does in its To Catch a Predator segment isn't journalism at all. It's entrapment, pure and simple. And capturing it on film turns it into something more closely resembling so-called "reality TV" than anything else--certainly more than journalism.

    The job of a journalist is to report events. What this segment of the show does isn't to report the events--it creates them. What's worse is that it puts the people caught on camera on trial in the court of public opinion. Many of the people who end up on the show end up having their cases dismissed in court for lack of evidence.

    If the police want to engage in this sort of activity, that's one thing. When a sensationalistic television show does it, unintended consequences happen.

    I have no sympathy for pediphiles. But engaging in entrapment to put them on television as a form of entertainment isn't the proper or ethical way to deal with them. Plus, it certainly isn't journalism, and it gives a bad name to those who do try to practice journalism in an ethical and principled manner.

    Unfortunately, a $105 million lawsuit isn't going to do much to change Dateline's practices. The show stays on the air because it gets reasonably good ratings and is dirt cheap to produce. That's why they put it on in every time slot where another show fails. Even with the occasional nine-figure lawsuit thrown in, it's far cheaper to produce than any sitcom.

    If you don't like the direction this country or society is headed, thank shows like this. Sensationalism and celebrity gossip is what passes for news these days, so the things that really matter don't even get mentioned.

    If you want to get your news from television, watch Jim Lehrer on PBS. Liberals think it's too conservative; conservatives think it's too liberal. That's usually an indication that it's doing something right. Flawed though it may be, at least it is journalism, unlike most of what ends up on television news anymore.

    I remember someone asking one of my journalism instructors (Bob Sullivan, now an MSNBC columnist) for an example of balanced journalism. Surprisingly, he didn't hesitate. "MacNeil/Lehrer," he said. Then he laughed. "And no one watches."

    Sad.

    I can find better journalism than Dateline without switching from NBC, however. It happens every Saturday night. Yes, I'm talking about Weekend Update. And it was better even when Norm McDonald was hosting.

      [ Views: 602 ]  


    Dateline's getting sued | 1 comments | Create New Account
    The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
    Dateline's getting sued
    Authored by: dhuff on Tuesday, July 31 2007 @ 08:36 AM CDT

    I'll preface this by saying that I absolutely agree with everything you've said about Dateline. Got no use for that sort of "journalism."

    But having said that, most of the folks in this part of the state (we live just a county or two west of where this happened) have zero sympathy for this guy. After all, he was on-line thinking he was setting up a sexual encounter with a 13-yr old boy. The newspaper editorials here in the Dallas area are running strongly towards this as an example of a "lawsuit-happy" culture.

    I think the whole situation is just sad.

    [ Reply to This ]

    What's Related
  • killed himself
  • Bob Sullivan
  • More by DaveF
  • More from Journalism

  • Story Options
  • Mail Story to a Friend
  • Printable Story Format


  • Calendar
    October 2008
    SuMoTuWeThFrSa
    28
    29
    30
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10
    11
    12
    13
    14
    15
    16
    17
    18
    19
    20
    21
    22
    23
    24
    25
    26
    27
    28
    29
    30
    31
    1
    Click on any day to see postings and events for that date.

    Referrals

    Top 10 by Comments
    Story TitleComments
    Cheap laptops from Sotec 253
    An untrustworthy vendor 164
    Upgrading an eMachine 125
    eMachine upgrade advice 99
    Why I dislike Microsoft 51
    Upgrade diary: Gateway G6-400 35
    And we're live 30
    The day after the Columbia 22
    How to pray 22
    CD-ROM troubleshooting under Windows 9x 20

    Top 10 Read
    Story TitleViews
    eMachine upgrade advice 67460
    Upgrading an eMachine 57773
    How to view a blg file in Windows 2000 38474
    Cheap laptops from Sotec 29897
    Upgrade diary: Compaq Presario 7360 18001
    Upgrade diary: Gateway G6-400 16942
    CD-ROM troubleshooting under Windows 9x 13830
    Finding an open-source alternative to Ghost 11874
    Big trouble 11188
    Salary cap? Baseball needs something 10467

    Topics
    Home
    Apache (2)
    Baseball (60)
    Book reviews (2)
    Business (1)
    Christianity (57)
    Cooking (1)
    Copyright (15)
    Curmudgeonry (1)
    Design (7)
    DOS (6)
    Games (4)
    Genealogy (10)
    General (498)
    Hardware (146)
    Health (13)
    Human Interest (9)
    Humor/Satire (19)
    Journalism (1)
    Linux (93)
    Macintosh (22)
    Model Building (2)
    Music (32)
    net.culture (40)
    Personal (80)
    Photography (6)
    Retro Computing (26)
    Saving money (58)
    Servers and Networking (17)
    Society (46)
    Software (49)
    Spam (13)
    St. Louis (23)
    This weblog (14)
    Toy trains (72)
    Troubleshooting (7)
    Vendors (6)
    Video (20)
    Viruses (12)
    Windows (116)
    Writing (16)

    Older Stories
    Tuesday 09-Sep
  • SSDs come of age? (0)

  • Sunday 07-Sep
  • My hot water heater: 1984-2008 (2)

  • Thursday 04-Sep
  • DOS nostalgia? (2)

  • Sunday 31-Aug
  • What does religion have to do with the United States falling behind in math and science? (3)

  • Thursday 28-Aug
  • Psst... Wanna compete with Best Buy? (4)

  • Friday 22-Aug
  • Why you should always stop at railroad crossings (0)

  • Wednesday 20-Aug
  • How to become a millionaire in 10 years (safely) (0)

  • Sunday 17-Aug
  • Why I still like Debian (2)

  • Thursday 14-Aug
  • Repainting rusty patio furniture (0)

  • Sunday 10-Aug
  • An old formula for making money (0)

  • Who's Online
    Guest Users: 5

    Syndicate!
    Get your RSS/RDF fix here.

    List of all stories
    Click here for a list of all the entries on this site


    Created this page in 1.36 seconds


     Copyright © 2008 Dave Farquhar's Silicon Underground
     All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners.

    Powered by GL 1.3.x